A Southern voting rights organization. A national consumer rights organization. A community behavioral health organization. A Fortune 500 energy company. A Western state corrections agency.
These organizations seem to have little in common, other than that we recruited each of their leaders, and each went on to a long, successful tenure.
Their deeper connection emerged during the searches. In each, the organization’s inherited culture and structure no longer matched its goals or the strategy needed to achieve them. Candid conversations we facilitated with our client and top candidates helped the parties understand that gap—and what closing it would require.
The voting rights organization: from founder-centered to shared leadership
The incoming executive knew election policy and the political battles over access to the polls, central to the organization’s mission. But he had less experience with its other work: voter education and registration, grassroots organizing, and get-out-the-vote programs.
Under the founder, nearly every decision had flowed from the top. Program leaders had little control over budgets or staffing. Rather than pretend to master every program, the new executive created a leadership team that shared authority and responsibility for strategy. The organization has since become widely regarded as the state’s leading nonpartisan voting rights and good-government group.
The consumer rights organization: from referee to honest broker
The organization had long fought for consumer rights, government accountability, workers’ rights and democracy, often through aggressive litigation and advocacy. That combative style also shaped its internal culture. Program directors competed for resources, with a powerful chief executive acting as referee. The arrangement depended heavily on the iconic leader at its center.
The new president did not claim the subject-matter expertise of the predecessor or program directors. Instead, the president brought the directors together to consider what the entire organization needed to succeed, serving as facilitator and honest broker. As trust grew, shared responsibility replaced internal battles. Today, Charity Navigator gives the organization a near-perfect rating for accountability and financial health.
The behavioral health organization: from family to enterprise
For more than 30 years, a large urban community behavioral health organization had been led by its founder, a gifted fundraiser and passionate advocate. As the organization expanded into addiction treatment, AIDS services, domestic violence programs, and psychiatric care, she continued to manage nearly everything herself. She called the organization a family; several employees were literally relatives. Senior managers had little independent authority.
Her successor shared the founder’s intelligence and commitment but brought experience managing professionally staffed behavioral health organizations.
The transition depended on frank discussions with the board about its expanded oversight responsibilities and with staff about the greater autonomy, accountability and scrutiny they would face. For many employees, the change opened opportunities to grow. Others moved into less demanding roles or left. Because the expectations were clear, the new leader could modernize the organization while retaining support from the board and staff.
The energy company: from tradition to innovation
For more than a century, this Fortune 500 energy company had relied on a near-monopoly in a large industrial market, a formidable legal department and an aggressive approach to regulators and advocates.
As we organized the CEO search, we raised a threat the company had not fully confronted: deregulation and competition in energy markets. Its longstanding dominance could no longer be taken for granted. That challenge became central to the search: how would the next CEO—and the board—respond?
The CEO we recruited brought unusual experience in both regulated and competitive energy markets. With the board’s support, the new leader preserved the engineering discipline essential to safe, reliable service while developing a more entrepreneurial, innovative and customer-focused culture. The crucial step was confronting the need for change openly—first during the search, then with employees. Adapting was not a fashionable initiative; it was essential to the company’s future.
The corrections agency: from command and control to rehabilitation
Few institutions are more rooted in command and control than prisons. When a newly elected governor engaged us to recruit a corrections director, we suggested that the search should look beyond traditional prison management. Behavioral health, addiction treatment, vocational education, policing and sentencing policies all shape corrections outcomes. The director we recruited, who had served in both Democratic- and Republican-led states, persuaded the governor that addressing these issues through policy and programming could better protect public safety over time.
He brought that philosophy into the agency, building a leadership team and linking staff incentives and promotions to rehabilitation and job-readiness measures. Progress has been gradual, but the workforce’s priorities are changing. The state’s plan to replace its century-old penitentiary with a facility designed for rehabilitation and reentry offers a tangible sign of that shift.
The pattern
Five sectors. Five very different missions. A common pattern: each leader inherited a culture shaped by conflict, centralized authority or a dominant personality—and helped align it with the organization’s future needs.
Credentials are visible on a résumé. The judgment to understand an inherited culture, and the ability to change it, are much harder to assess.
Why it matters in a search
We surfaced these challenges at the beginning of each search, not after the appointment. We invited boards and leading candidates to speak candidly about the organization as it was, the changes it needed and the leadership those changes would demand. That shared understanding gave each new executive—and each board—a stronger foundation from day one.