For many nonprofit governing boards, the cost of retaining an executive search firm is an important consideration when recruiting a new chief executive.
Professional fees for a comprehensive retained executive search are frequently calculated at approximately 25% to 33⅓% of the successful candidate's first-year compensation. Other firms establish a fixed fee based on the scope and complexity of the engagement. Some have minimum fees and charge separately for search-related expenses.
There can, however, be considerable differences in the work performed by firms charging comparable fees.
What can a nonprofit expect to pay?
The following examples illustrate percentage-based professional fees. They are not a Ford Webb Associates fee schedule.
| Annual compensation | Fee at 25% | Fee at 33⅓% |
|---|---|---|
| $100,000 | $25,000 | $33,333 |
| $150,000 | $37,500 | $50,000 |
| $200,000 | $50,000 | $66,667 |
| $250,000 | $62,500 | $83,333 |
| $300,000 | $75,000 | $100,000 |
Actual fees may vary with the pricing structure, minimum fee, complexity and additional expenses. Establish whether the fee is calculated on base salary or includes bonuses and other compensation.
What are you paying for?
A comprehensive engagement may include:
- Independent organizational assessment and confidential stakeholder interviews
- Identification of strategic priorities and leadership requirements
- Preparation of a substantive position profile
- Research, candidate networking and direct outreach
- In-depth candidate assessment and search committee guidance
- Reference inquiries and negotiation assistance
- Preparation for the incoming executive’s transition
Some firms concentrate principally on identifying and recruiting candidates. Others undertake considerable organizational assessment and strategic counsel. Understanding these differences is essential when comparing proposals.
Different approaches to executive search
Comprehensive retained executive search
The organization retains a consultant to manage the principal dimensions of the search, from organizational assessment through recruitment, evaluation and appointment. This is particularly appropriate when extensive national networking, complex leadership challenges or limited internal capacity warrant professional management.
Contingency recruitment
A recruiter is ordinarily compensated when a candidate they have presented is hired. Boards should consider whether this arrangement provides sufficient organizational assessment, candidate development and committee support for a chief executive appointment.
Board-led executive search with professional advisory services
Some boards have the professional networks, staff resources and capacity to recruit their next executive themselves. Independent counsel can help assess the organization, define leadership needs, structure the process and evaluate finalists. The organization retains responsibility for candidate recruitment and administration. This can be a more affordable alternative to comprehensive search.
Comparing search firm proposals
- What work is included in the professional fee, and who will personally perform it?
- Will the consultant undertake an independent organizational assessment?
- How will prospective candidates be identified and recruited?
- What additional expenses might we incur?
- Will the fee change if the appointee’s compensation exceeds expectations?
- What happens if the search is unsuccessful, needs to be extended or the appointee leaves prematurely?
- What assistance will be provided following the appointment?
A lower fee does not necessarily represent better value, just as a higher fee does not necessarily assure a more comprehensive or effective search.
The costs of an unsuccessful leadership transition
The direct costs of a search should be considered in relation to the potential consequences of an unsuccessful appointment.
A poorly conceived leadership transition can result in the loss of valued staff, declining confidence among funders, strained governance relationships, interruptions in programs and the expense of recruiting another chief executive. The costs to the organization and those it serves may substantially exceed the original investment in search.
An effective search should address not only candidate qualifications but the organizational circumstances that will determine whether the next chief executive can succeed.
Finding the right approach for your organization
Not every organization needs the full range of services provided by a comprehensive executive search firm. The appropriate approach depends on the organization's circumstances, the complexity of the assignment, the board's capacity and the resources available.
Ford Webb Associates offers comprehensive retained executive search and Search Advisory for organizations managing their own recruitment. Advisory work ordinarily begins with a focused organizational assessment. Together with the board, we determine what additional assistance, if any, would best serve the organization. Scope, responsibilities and fees are established in advance.
An investment in organizational performance
The most important question is ultimately not how much it will cost to recruit a chief executive, but what investment is necessary to establish the conditions for successful leadership.
A thoughtful executive search can establish a shared understanding of the organization's direction and strengthen the relationship between the board and its incoming leader. That is an investment in the institution itself.
For further information about fee arrangements, see the Council on Foundations’ Hiring a New CEO Resource Guide.